Articles

Family Silence: Its Dangers and Remedy
Author : Dr. Mohammad bani Taha
Date Added : 22-11-2026

Family Silence: Its Dangers and Remedy

The enormous technological progress the world is witnessing, advancing daily if not by the moment, has cast its shadow over every area of civil life for the individual and for society: economics, health, social life, and even individual behavior.

The great positive effects of this progress on the life of the individual and society cannot be denied. It has made the means of living easy and accessible, so that the ordinary person enjoys a comfort and abundance that even emperors and sultans of the past could not have dreamed of.

Yet, this progress has also had serious negative effects. Under its influence, the individual has at times drifted toward individualism, selfishness, and isolation, which threaten the basic building block of society. Recent global studies and statistics have found that the average conversation between spouses is about five minutes a day, that a mother spends less than an hour a day with her children, and a father less than a quarter of an hour. Even advanced countries such as the United Kingdom have created a ministry dedicated to combating social loneliness. [1]

One result of this drift toward individualism, selfishness, and isolation is the emergence of the phenomenon of family silence. By this we mean the decline of communication among the members of the family, verbal and sometimes non-verbal, and in other cases its complete absence, owing to the lack of dialogue and mutual understanding.

This phenomenon has serious effects on the individual and on society, which may be summarized as follows: [2]

First: A rise in divorce, especially early divorce, and the family breakdown that follows. Family silence, together with the spouses’ withdrawal from one another, coldness of feeling, lack of understanding and dialogue, and the absence of affection and intimacy between them, is among the most important causes of divorce and its spread.

Second: Serious psychological effects, including constant anxiety, recurring tension, and severe depression arising from feelings of loneliness and isolation. These damaging effects appear especially in children, who are the weakest link in the family. Such grave psychological disturbances have far-reaching consequences that leave society fragmented and weak, unable to defend its existence or preserve its civilizational identity.

Third: Emotional coldness between the spouses, the absence of affection and mercy, and consequently an emotional void. This may be followed by moral and behavioral deviations on the part of one of the spouses that can end family life in divorce.

Fourth: Serious behavioral deviations and disturbances, especially among children, resulting from the absence of parental attention and educational guidance. This pushes them into the arms of bad companions, and they are drawn into the inferno of addiction and delinquency.

Recent regional studies on “digital emotional safety and artificial intelligence” (2024-2026) have shown that girls who lack the language of listening and warmth at home are 70% more likely to fall into the trap of “online blackmail,” because they seek affection in the digital space. Other girls have turned to AI-based chat rooms (AI companions) as a secret, emotionally destructive substitute for their parents. [3]

Fifth: The effects of family silence may not be limited to children’s mental health but may extend to physical health. A study by Princeton University in the United States (“The Organic and Biological Impact of Father Absence”), whose initial findings were published in October 2017 and whose applications have since been renewed worldwide, showed that the loss of fathers directly affects children’s physical health and longevity. The absence of the father shortens telomeres, the protective caps at the ends of chromosomes that serve as an indicator of biological age within cells, by the following percentages: parental separation or divorce shortens telomere length by 6%; the father’s imprisonment shortens it by 10%; and losing the father at the age of five raises the damage in boys, shortening telomeres by 16%. [4]

Sixth: All of this produces a weak, fragmented society eaten away by psychological illness and moral and behavioral problems, and a fertile environment for crime of every kind. Such a society becomes fragile and frail, unable to defend its resources, its identity, or its gains.

In the face of these very serious effects of family silence on the individual and on society, it has become necessary for efforts to come together, among individuals and official institutions alike, to confront this phenomenon and devise an effective remedy.

To devise the remedy and confront this dangerous phenomenon, we must understand its roots and causes and address them, either by preventing it before it occurs or by treating it once it has appeared. The most important causes of family silence may be summarized as follows:

First: Religious causes, namely neglect of the principles for choosing a spouse that Islam urged both men and women to observe in choosing the one they will be joined to. Instead of choosing on the basis of character and religion, the basis and standard have become the partner’s economic and social standing.

The remedy for this cause is anticipatory and preventive. The Sharīʿah called for good character and religion to be the two bases for choosing a life partner. It guided the man with the words of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him): “A woman is sought in marriage for four things: her wealth, her family standing, her beauty, and her religious devotion. Win the one who is religiously devoted—may you prosper.” Agreed upon. It also guided the woman and her guardian with his words: “If someone whose character and religion you are pleased with comes to you, marry him to her. If you do not, there will be strife on earth and widespread corruption.” [Sunan Ibn Mājah, Chapter on Equals (al-Akfāʾ), vol. 1, p. 632]

Second: Psychological causes, namely loss of self-confidence because of earlier experiences of negative dialogue and discussion and misunderstanding among family members, arising from a failure to respect differences in how people express their feelings. They then prefer to withdraw into silence for fear of embarrassment.

The remedy for this cause has two dimensions:

(a) Preventive. The noble Sharīʿah calls on the suitor to take the permissible gaze, so that understanding and compatibility develop between the engaged couple. Dialogue and discussion between them afterward then rest on a solid ground of mutual respect for each other’s style of discussion and of expressing opinions and feelings.

(b) Curative. The Islamic Sharīʿah took care to promote a culture of effective communication and the art of dialogue between spouses, and to explain the importance of dialogue between them and of choosing the best words, particularly when opinions differ. Allah the Exalted commanded us: “And tell My servants to say that which is best” [al-Isrāʾ/53].

It also called for ordering family relations and ensuring their stability by stressing the etiquette of dialogue and discussion and forbidding the mocking of others, whether in the way they argue or in the free expression of their opinions. It considered all this among the family rights that must be observed.

Third: Social causes, namely what is known as family withdrawal. It is regarded as a defense mechanism, but a negative social one, because the person who withdraws resorts to it to escape his own tensions. It is often followed by family silence. The spouses grow used to the absence of warmth until silence becomes part of the nature of the relationship, and the distance between them becomes a familiar thing that prompts no questions.

The remedy is to remove all causes of tension and of fear of voicing an opinion or taking part in discussion, and to spread a sense of psychological safety among family members, by establishing values of mutual respect based on understanding differences of opinion and of the way of expressing them.

Fourth: Causes related to the nature of life. The individual suffers from work pressure and comes home weighed down by it, with his energy and capacity for dialogue drained, so he inclines to silence, having no strength left for discussion and conversation. [5]

The remedy is to provide ample room for rest from the pressures of livelihood and the worries of life, by choosing suitable times and places for family discussions and taking care to wrap those discussions in affection and mutual respect.

Fifth: Economic causes. The financial and living burdens of the family occupy a large share of the thinking of the two pillars of the family. They fall under pressure and tension and leave no space for discussion and dialogue, so they take refuge in silence to escape further pressure and tension from conversation.

This cause can be addressed by spreading a spirit of cooperation and solidarity among family members in sharing the family’s financial and living burdens. This opens up room for constructive discussion and dialogue, especially when each side bears the concern of keeping the family together.

Sixth: Preoccupation with the technology and online communication applications that smartphones provide. Instead of spending more time communicating with family members, people spend it on social media in the virtual world. This destroys opportunities for understanding and dialogue among family members and leads them into the depths of family silence.

The remedy is to reduce and regulate the time they spend on smartphones and, in return, to increase the space for communication among family members, which spreads affection and understanding among them.

In conclusion, confronting family silence, which threatens family and society alike, is everyone’s responsibility, individuals and institutions, in working to spread a culture of dialogue and understanding and the etiquette of positive discussion among family members and in society. It cannot be remedied except through the combined efforts of all.

________________________________________

References

[1] Symposium titled “Family Silence as a Cause of Early Divorce,” Faculty of Islamic Studies, Hamad Bin Khalifa University.

[2] Family Silence and Its Remedy, a study by Dr. Asmāʾ Ṣāliḥ, Al-Azhar University, Issue 36, 2024.

[3] The Lost Immunization: Family Dialogue, from Digital Silence to the Tremors That Undermine Girls’ Stability, Riḍā Muḥammad al-Sayyid, Manār al-Islām Journal for Research and Studies.

[4] Ibid.

[5] An article on remedying silence between spouses, on the platform Shāwirnī.

Article Number [ Previous | Next ]

Read for Author




Comments


Captcha


Warning: this window is not dedicated to receive religious questions, but to comment on topics published for the benefit of the site administrators—and not for publication. We are pleased to receive religious questions in the section "Send Your Question". So we apologize to readers for not answering any questions through this window of "Comments" for the sake of work organization. Thank you.




Summarized Fatawaa

What is the monetary value for the expiation of an oath (Kaffarat al-Yamin)?

Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our Master, the Messenger of Allah.
 
The expiation for an oath (Kaffarat al-Yamin) consists of feeding ten (10) needy persons. This is estimated at 600 grams of rice per person. It is also permissible to pay its value in cash, which is estimated at one dinar (per person). And Allah the Exalted knows best.

Is it permissible to consume the meat of a sacrifice (Dhabihah) offered as an act of devotion to Allah, seeking His protection for my family?

Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our Master, the Messenger of Allah.
 
It is permissible to eat from this sacrifice, and the reward [for it] is according to what is given to the poor. And Allah the Exalted knows best.

What is the ruling on using the *subḥah* (prayer beads) to count during *tasbīḥ* and *dhikr*?

All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our master, the Messenger of Allah.
It is recommended to use the ordinary or electronic subḥah (prayer beads or counter) to count tasbīḥ, dhikr, and istighfār, because it helps one to remember Allah. Many reports have been transmitted from the Companions and the Followers (tābiʿūn) showing that they continued to use strings of date pits as an aid to dhikr and tasbīḥ.
It is one of the lawful means of worship. Indeed, what is established from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), namely that he counted tasbīḥ on his right hand, shows that it is permissible to count tasbīḥ with whatever helps a Muslim keep track of the number. There is therefore no basis for calling it an innovation (bidʿah), and we know of no jurist who said so.
Al-Ḥāfiẓ al-Suyūṭī (may Allah have mercy on him) wrote a dedicated treatise on the subject titled al-Minḥah fī al-Subḥah, printed within al-Ḥāwī li’l-Fatāwī (vol. 4–6).
Shaykh al-Islām Imam Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked: Does the subḥah have a basis in the Sunnah? He replied: “Yes, and al-Ḥāfiẓ al-Suyūṭī wrote on this. Among the evidence is what is authentically reported from Ibn ʿUmar (may Allah be pleased with them both): ‘I saw the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) counting tasbīḥ on his hand.’ Ibn Abī Shaybah, Abū Dāwūd, and al-Tirmidhī also narrated: ‘Hold fast to tasbīḥ, tahlīl, and taqdīs, and do not be heedless, lest you forget the affirmation of Allah’s oneness (tawḥīd). Count them on the fingertips, for they will be questioned and made to speak.’ Counting tasbīḥ with pebbles, date pits, and a knotted string has also been reported from a group of the Companions and those after them. Some scholars held that counting on the fingertips is better than the subḥah, based on the ḥadīth of Ibn ʿUmar. Others distinguished, saying: if the one reciting is safe from miscounting, counting on the fingertips is better; otherwise the subḥah is better.” [al-Fatāwā al-Fiqhiyyah al-Kubrā, Vol.1/p.152]. And Allah Almighty knows best.

Is it permissible for one who sacrifices on behalf of another, with the latter's permission, to eat from the sacrifice?

It is permissible for someone who sacrificed on behalf of another with their permission to eat from it with their permission, and they stand in their place (act as their representative) in distributing it.
 
It is stated in Nihayat al-Muhtaj ila Sharh al-Minhaj (Vol.8/P.141): "And he—meaning the one sacrificing on his own behalf, provided he has not apostatized—has the right to eat from a voluntary sacrifice and his sacrificial gift; rather, it is recommended. As for an obligatory sacrifice, it is forbidden for him to eat from it, whether it was designated as such initially or as a liability in his dhimmah. And excluded by what has preceded is if he sacrifices on behalf of another, or if he apostatized, then it is not permissible for him to eat from it, just as it is absolutely impermissible to feed a disbeliever from it."(The text I found indicates the impermissibility of eating) ???
 
And it is stated in Hashiyat al-Jamal ‘ala Sharh al-Manhaj (Vol.5/P.262): "If a person offers a sacrifice on behalf of a living person with their permission, does he act as their representative in distributing it—on the grounds that permission to sacrifice is permission to distribute it—or does it depend on their explicit permission? This requires consideration, but the first view is not far-fetched." And Allah the Almighty knows best.