Articles

Jurisprudential Madhhabism: A Middle Path between Two Extremes
Author : Dr. Mufti. Jadallah Bassam
Date Added : 05-01-2025

Jurisprudential Madhhabism: A Middle Path between Two Extremes

An Islamic legal ruling is based on established principles and evidence, serving as the foundation for all reasoning and issues, as it reflects the will of Allah The Almighty. He is the One who commands and prohibits, defining what is lawful (Halal) and unlawful (Haram). These determinations are not subject to human opinions, nor are they left to the whims and desires of people. The role of scholars, jurists, and muftis is to clarify the ruling of Allah. We are instructed to adhere strictly to Allah's commandments without exceeding them. Allah Says in the Quran (What means): "But say not - for any false thing that your tongues may put forth,- "This is lawful, and this is forbidden," so as to ascribe false things to God. For those who ascribe false things to God, will never prosper." [An-Nahl/116].
This foundational understanding of the concept of Islamic legal rulings, and its clear impact on defining the duties of muftis, judges, and scholars, is best demonstrated in its pure and correct form according to the principles of Ahlus-Sunnah Wal-Jama'ah. This stands in contrast to those who deviate into extremism, being either excessive or unjust, transgressing and overstepping the boundaries of what Allah The Almighty has revealed to His Messenger (PBUH). The clarification of this includes the following:
Ahlus-Sunnah Wal-Jama'ah have taken a balanced position between two extremes of extremism:
The First Group: This group prohibits examining evidence altogether and forbids Ijtihad (independent reasoning). Among the early sects holding such views were the Hashawiyyah, Batiniyyah, Ta'limiyyah, and extreme factions of the Hashashin, among others. They believe in following a particular teacher without any critical consideration, whether in matters of creed or jurisprudence and its principles. They claim that truth can only be known through the teachings of this teacher, whom they refer to as "the instructor" (Al-Mu'allim), hence their designation as the Ta'limiyyah or People of Instruction. The Second Group: This group mandates examining evidence in all cases and prohibits seeking guidance from scholars. In early sects, they included certain factions of the Qadariyyah. Some within this group denied consensus (Ijma'), claiming that one must rely solely on evidence. Examples include the Khawarij, some Mu'tazilah, and certain Shi'ah. Among contemporary intellectual movements, they include modernists, self-proclaimed "enlightened" and "rationalists," and those who reject adherence to traditional Islamic schools of thought (Madhahib). These groups obligate individuals to derive all rulings from the primary sources of Islamic law, whether related to creed or jurisprudence. They even reject referring to the opinions of esteemed scholars and the major schools of Islamic jurisprudence in the most intricate of issues. All of these factions assert that a person must derive the rulings they need directly from the foundational texts without relying on the expertise of jurists and scholars, though each faction expresses its views and beliefs in its own terms.
As for Ahlus-Sunnah Wal-Jama'ah, their stance is balanced and moderate, adhering to the definitive evidences of Shariah and the consensus (Ijma') of the Ummah. They uphold the obligation of Ijtihad, contemplation, and adherence to both rational and textual evidence in matters of creed and foundational principles. They believe it is a religious obligation upon every accountable individual (Mukallaf) to ascertain these matters through evidence and to recognize the principle of adhering to the established and credible schools of jurisprudence (Madhahib) while refraining from deviating from them. For this reason, consensus was reached on the necessity of following these schools after their establishment and widespread acceptance, as narrated by numerous scholars in works on jurisprudence and its principles.
This balanced stance of Ahlus-Sunnah Wal-Jama'ah, emphasizing the obligation of laypeople to follow qualified jurists and experts among the scholars of jurisprudence (Fuqaha), is supported by numerous Shariah evidences. Among them are:
The verse: "if ye realise this not, ask of those who possess the Message."
[An-Nahl/43].
The verse:" When there comes to them some matter touching (Public) safety or fear, they divulge it. If they had only referred it to the Apostle, or to those charged with authority among them, the proper investigators would have Tested it from them (direct). Were it not for the Grace and Mercy of God unto you, all but a few of you would have fallen into the clutches of Satan."
[An-Nisa/83].
The verse: "Nor should the Believers all go forth together: if a contingent from every expedition remained behind, they could devote themselves to studies in religion, and admonish the people when they return to them,- that thus they (may learn) to guard themselves (against evil)."
[At-Tawbah/122].
This is in addition to other similar evidences from the Shariah.                       The positions of the deviant sects, driven by extremism, have caused significant disruption in the structure of the Islamic society. This has led to the spread of Fitan (trials) such as Takfir (excommunication), Tazlil (misguidance), and Tabdi' (innovation), as well as the proliferation of movements that applied erroneous principles, either in the form of intellectual or military calls. This disruption is not limited to a single aspect of life; rather, it has a broad and pervasive impact, affecting all areas of individual and family life. It extends further to institutions and the sectors overseen by the state.
Hence, the methodology of Ahl Al-Sunnah, and what they have unanimously agreed upon in following the established jurisprudential schools, is a solid scientific foundation in demonstrating servitude to the Lord of the worlds and practicing aspects of worldly life with ease and openness. Their methodology is the most just and the most appropriate in attaining human interests, preventing harms to people, and achieving both worldly and eternal happiness. It is therefore obligatory upon us to follow the path laid down by our scholars and the methods they have derived from sound scientific principles.

 

 

 

Article Number [ Previous | Next ]

Read for Author




Comments


Captcha


Warning: this window is not dedicated to receive religious questions, but to comment on topics published for the benefit of the site administrators—and not for publication. We are pleased to receive religious questions in the section "Send Your Question". So we apologize to readers for not answering any questions through this window of "Comments" for the sake of work organization. Thank you.




Summarized Fatawaa

Is it permissible to eat from an Udhiyah slaughtered on behalf of a deceased person?

Praise be to Allah, and prayers and peace be upon our Master the Messenger of Allah.
 
It is permissible to eat from the sacrifice (uḍḥiyyah) that is offered on behalf of a deceased person. This is the madhhab (school of thought) of the Hanbalis. In this case, the heirs take the place of the deceased as if he were alive, with the same rights to eat from it, give it in charity, and offer it as a gift.
 
It is stated in Maṭālib Uli al-Nuhā (Vol.2/P.472): "Offering a sacrifice on behalf of a deceased person is better than offering one on behalf of a living person, because the deceased is unable (to perform deeds) and is in need of reward. It is to be treated like a sacrifice on behalf of a living person in terms of eating, giving charity, and giving gifts." And Allah Almighty knows best.

What is the ruling on one who vows to fast a specific or non-specific year? Are the two Eids, the days of Tashreeq, Ramadan, and the days of menstruation and postnatal bleeding included in them? And do these days break the consecutiveness if it was intended?

Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our Master, the Messenger of Allah.
 
If someone makes a vow (Nadr) to fast a specific, designated year, this vow does not include the days of Eid, the days of Tashreeq (the three days following Eid al-Adha), Ramadan, or the days of menstruation (Hayd) and postnatal bleeding (Nifas). Furthermore, there is no requirement to make up (Qada) these specific days.
 
However, if someone vows to fast a year that is not specifically designated (i.e., any twelve-month period) and stipulates that the fasting must be consecutive, they are bound by that condition. They must not fast on the days of Eid, during Ramadan, or during menstruation, but they are required to make up these days afterward—with the exception of the days of menstruation and postnatal bleeding, which do not need to be made up.
 
It is stated in Hashiyat al-Bajuri ‘ala Sharh Ibn Qasim ({Vol.2/P.606): 'If one vows to fast a specific year, the Eid, Tashreeq, Ramadan, and days of menstruation or postnatal bleeding are not included. This is because Ramadan does not accept any fast other than its own, and the others do not accept fasting at all. Therefore, they do not enter into the vow, and no makeup is required for them because they are legally excluded—contrary to Al-Rafi’i regarding menstruation and postnatal bleeding.
 
If one vows to fast a non-designated year: if they stipulated consecutiveness (Tatuabu’) in their vow, they must fulfill it; otherwise, they are not bound to it. Consecutiveness is not broken by the days that do not enter into the specific year vow (Eid, Tashreeq, Ramadan, menstruation, and postnatal bleeding). However, one must make up the days missed—excluding the time of menstruation and postnatal bleeding—immediately following the end of the year. As for the time of menstruation and postnatal bleeding, it is not made up, contrary to Ibn al-Rif’ah, who argued that it must be made up just like Ramadan.' And Allah the Exalted knows best.

What is the ruling on combining more than one intention in the prayer, such as combining the *sunnah* of wuḍūʾ with the pre-Dhuhr *sunnah*, or combining the *sunnah* of greeting the mosque (*taḥiyyat al-masjid*) with the pre-Dhuhr *sunnah*?

All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our master, the Messenger of Allah.
Combining two intentions in a single act of worship, which some jurists call the “overlapping of acts of worship”, has several cases and precise rules. These can be consulted in the books of legal maxims, such as al-Manthūr fī al-Qawāʿid al-Fiqhiyyah by al-Zarkashī and al-Ashbāh wa’l-Naẓāʾir by al-Suyūṭī. Among the most important of these rules:
First: If all of the acts of worship that one wishes to combine under one intention are obligatory, the intentions do not overlap. An example is combining the intention of the obligatory ʿAṣr prayer with that of the obligatory Dhuhr prayer. The intentions do not overlap in this case.
Second: If the two acts are specified supererogatory prayers (nawāfil muqayyadah) that are aimed at in themselves because of a particular time, occasion, or cause, or if they are an obligatory prayer and a specified supererogatory prayer, the intentions again do not overlap. An example is the Duha prayer, which may not be combined with, for instance, the regular sunnah of Dhuhr.
It is stated in Bushrā al-Karīm: “Whatever is not, in meaning, an absolute voluntary prayer, such as the Duha sunnah… is not subsumed under another. Rather, if he intends something else along with it… the prayer is not validly entered. This is because combining two obligations, two specified supererogatory prayers, or an obligation and a specified supererogatory prayer invalidates the prayer in cases not built upon overlapping, as ritual purification (ṭahārah) is.”
Third: If the two acts are absolute voluntary prayers (nawāfil muṭlaqah), or one of them is, where the texts of the Sharīʿah show that the aim of the voluntary act is to fill the time with worship, then overlapping of intentions is permissible. An example is the obligatory Dhuhr prayer together with the sunnah of greeting the mosque (taḥiyyat al-masjid). And Allah Almighty knows best.

I vowed to give a specific charity if a certain matter came to pass — what is the ruling on giving that charity before the matter is realised?

All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon our master the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
Fulfilling a vow (nadhr) is obligatory, in accordance with the word of Allah the Almighty: "And let them fulfil their vows." [Al-Ḥajj/ 29] And the saying of our master the Messenger of Allah ﷺ: "Whoever vows to obey Allah, let him obey Him; and whoever vows to disobey Him, let him not disobey Him." (Reported by al-Bukhārī.)
The Shāfiʿī scholars distinguished between a financial vow (nadhr mālī) and a bodily vow (nadhr badanī). They permitted the fulfilment of a financial vow to be brought forward — before the stipulated condition is met — but did not permit the same for a bodily vow, which may only be fulfilled after the condition has actually been realised.
Shaykh al-Islām Imām Zakariyyā al-Anṣārī, may Allah have mercy upon him, states: "It is permissible to bring forward the fulfilment of a financial vow before the condition stipulated in it is met — such as saying: 'If I am healed, I vow to free a slave' or 'to give such-and-such in charity' — just as it is permissible to pay zakāh in advance. This is unlike a bodily vow, such as fasting." [Asnā al-Maṭālib, vol. 4/P.246]
Imām al-Bājūrī, may Allah have mercy upon him, states: "Like expiation other than fasting, a financial vow — such as saying: 'If Allah heals my sick one, I vow to free a slave for the sake of Allah,' or 'If Allah heals my sick one, I vow to free a slave on the Friday following the recovery' — it is permissible to bring it forward before the recovery in the first case, and before the Friday following the recovery in the second case." [Ḥāshiyat al-Bājūrī ʿalā Sharḥ Ibn Qāsim, Vol.2/P.596] And Allah the Almighty knows best.